Judges Who Have Served the Court During The Last 223 Years of The Town’s History 1786-2009
| Judges Since 1786 | ||
| Name | Term(s) | Years of Service |
| BENJAMIN COE | (1786-90 & 1810) | 6 years |
| THOMAS BLAUVELT | (1786 – 1795) | 10 years |
| JOHN SUFFERN | (1789) | 1 year |
| JAMES CUPPER | (1789) | 1 year |
| THOMAS CUPPER | (1789) | 1 year |
| WALTER SMITH | (1790 – 1791 & 1794 – 1798) | 7 years |
| JOHN CULEMAN | (1792 – 1795) | 4 years |
| JOHN BLAUVELT | (1795 – 1809) | 15 years |
| JOHN LYDECKER | (1801) | 1 year |
| JAMES STANDHILL | (1802 – 1804) | 3 years |
| PETER SMITH | (1804 – 1809) (1811 – 1812) (1815 – 1818) (1823 – 1825) | 15 years |
| JAMES VANDERBILT | (1805 – 1806 & 1810) | 3 years |
| RESULVERT STEPHANS | (1807-1809 & 1811-1820) | 12 years |
| JAMES STEPHANS | (1817 – 1819 & 1821) | 4 years |
| EBENEZER WOOD | (1818 – 1821) | 4 years |
| PETER STEPHENS | (1820) | 1 year |
| ALBERT LYDECKER | (1821 – 1830 – 1832) | 4 years |
| WILLIAM STUART | (1821) | 1 year |
| ABRAHAM STEPHENS | (1822 – 1835 & 1837) | 14 years |
| THOMAS HOWARD | (1822 – 1827) | 6 years |
| HENRY HOUSE | (1828 – 1829) | 2 years |
| JACOB BLAUVELT | (1828 – 1838)* | 11 years |
| JOHN STAGG | (1828 – 1836) | 9 years |
| JOHN BLANCH | (1834 – 1838)* (1858 – 1861 & 1863) | 10 years |
| PETER STEPHENS | (1838 – * & 1858-1867) | 11 YEARS |
| CHARLES FULLWOOD | (1838 – ?)* | |
| FABER WOOD | (1857 – 1858) | 2 years |
| JABEZ WOOD | (1858 – 1865) | 8 years |
| AUSTIN FITCH | (1859 – 1862) | 5 years |
| ISAAC TALLMAN | (1862 – 1872) | 11 years |
| HARVEY SMITH | (1862 – 1880) (1884 – 1886) | 22 years |
| FREDERICK WHILES | (1865 – 1874) (1881 – 1895) | 25 years |
| DANIEL CLARK | (1867 – 1879) | 13 years |
| ANDREW CORSA | (1872 – 1873) | 2 years |
| ISAAC STRERND | (1872) | 1 year |
| HARRY HAIGHT | (1873 – 1880) | 8 years |
| ABRAHAM DICKEY | (1873 – 1876) | 4 years |
| CORTLAND SPRAGUE | (1876 – 1879) | 4 years |
| WILLIAM CALL | (1876) | 1 year |
| FRANK DEMAREST | (1878 – 1893) | 6 years |
| JOHN RILEY | (1880 – 1884) | 4 years |
| TUNIS BLAUVELT | (1880 – 1885) | 5 years |
| DAVID BENSON | (1883 – 1884) | 2 years |
| JOSEPH KELLY | (1884 – 1888) | 5 years |
| FRANCIS TALLMAN | (1885) | 1 year |
| WILLIAM SCHEK | (1885 – 1894) (1898 – 1901) (1905 – 1917) | 27 years |
| EDWARD CULE | (1885) | 1 year |
| JOHN POMEROY | (1886) | 1 year |
| MARSH CROPSEY | (1887) | 1 year |
| GEORGE REIMER | (1887 – 1900) (1902 – 1919) | 32 years |
| THOMAS LAWRENCE | (1888 – 1889) | 2 years |
| GEORGE WYRE | (1889 – 1898) | 10 years |
| CHARLES FISCHER | (1893 – 1894) | 2 years |
| GEORGE HAERLE | (1894 – 1919) | 26 years |
| JACOB VANDERBILT | (1895 – 1899) | 5 years |
| W.WYARD | (1896 & 1898 – 1899) | 3 years |
| M. CHRISTIE | (1897) | 1 year |
| THEODORE DENOYELLES | (1899 – 1906) | 8 years |
| HARRY FISCHER | (1902 – 1905) | 4 years |
| JOHN SCHMERSAHL | (1907 – 1925) (1927 – 1931) | 24 years |
| F. GUSTAVE GRUMHULD | (1917 – 1918) (1921 – 1925) | 7 years |
| RAYMOND BLAUVELT | (1917 – 1919) | 3 years |
| GEORGE LINK JR. | (1919 – 1931) | 13 years |
| WARD CULLINS | (1919 – 1921) | 3 years |
| WILLIAM McVICKAR | (1919 – 1921) | 3 years |
| ROBERT LIEBERT | (1922 – 1924) | 3 years |
| WILLIAM HAMBLIN | (1923 – 1927) (1929 – 1933) | 10 years |
| E.H. JULIFFE | (1925 – 1929) | 5 years |
| RAYMOND FISHER | (1925 – 1937) | 13 years |
| JOHN HILL | (1931 – 1933) | 3 years |
| SAMUEL GARRISON | (1931 – Died 1940) | 10 years |
| STEVEN FLAMIK | (1933 – 1937) | 5 years |
| FRED R. ENGELS | (1938 – 1949) | 12 years |
| CHARLES J. BLAUVELT | (1940 & 1952-1959) | 9 years |
| IRVING F. DILLON | (1940 – 1945)1 | 6 years |
| THEODORE F. MEIER | (1947) | 1 year |
| EDWARD G. ROEPE | (1947 Appointed to fill T.F.Meier’s Term) | 1 year |
| STEPHEN DOIG, JR. | (1946 & 1948 – 1951) (1970-1971) | 7 years |
| JOHN A. STEFAN | (1950 – 1965) | 16 years |
| WILLIAM E. VINES | (1960 – 1969)2 | 10 years |
| EDWARD J. FLYNN | (1966 – 1981) | 16 years |
| ROBERT MAIDMAN | (1972 – 1979) | 8 years |
| WILLIAM WRAY | (1978 – Resigned 1991) | 14 years |
| MURRAY JACOBSON | (1980 – 1983) | 4 years |
| WILLIAM A. KELLY | (1982 – 1987) | 6 years |
| HARRY WAITZMAN | (1982 – Resigned in 1991) | 10 years |
| KENNETH S. RONES | (1984 – 1995) | 12 years |
| VICTOR VITALE | (1988) | 1 year |
| VICTOR J. ALFIERI, JR. | (1989 – 2006) | 18 years |
| HARRY EDELSTEIN | (1991 – 1993) | 3 years |
| SCOTT B. UGELL | (1991 – PRESENT) | |
| CLARE McCUE CINCOTTA | (1993) | ½ year |
| CRAIG E. JOHNS | (1993 – PRESENT) | |
| JOEL J. FLICK | (1996 – 2008) | 12 years |
| HOWARD GERBER | (2007 – PRESENT) | |
| ROLF THORSEN | (2008-2014) | 6 years |
| David Ascher (2014 to Present) | (2014 to Present) | |
*Records from 1839-1856 missing
1Later became Supervisor of the Town
2Later became Supervisor of the Town